I had a non-implant operation after too much cartilage was ground down, but it resulted in a pointed, Pinocchio-like nose, so I want to have it removed. Also, my septum deviated again to the opposite side, making me very uncomfortable
Clinic A: They suggested only shortening the septal support and repositioning the cartilage. They said removing the cartilage that had been ground down and adhered, then removing everything, could make the tip drop below its original state, so they advised against it. If they open it up and there is a possibility of a saddle nose, ear cartilage could be taken out, but that would cost extra. They diagnosed it only by palpation. They said it would be better not to touch the deviated septum and just live with it.
Clinic B: They used ultrasound, so they could check what had been inserted. They firmly said that even with complete removal, repositioning the cartilage again would prevent the tip from dropping below its original state. With complete removal, the front view would return to its original appearance, which was somewhat bulbous, long, and drooping, and that was why I had surgery. If I want to preserve some of the front-view appearance, they can shorten the septal support and leave some material in place, but the tip would remain hard. The ultrasound showed that not much septum had been used, so we decided to reduce the septum, correct the deviation, and shave down the dorsal hump to lower the height a little. I definitely decided to have this done either way!!
There was no price difference, and both allow revisions or aftercare within four years. I am so torn T_T The prices were similar, and Clinic B said that because the cartilage had been ground down, the tip might become uneven later, so removal would probably be better. They said it would be fine if that did not bother me... Anyway, the height is too high, so I will definitely reduce or remove it, but I am also deliberating over the clinic and whether to have complete or partial removal