Help me choose a clinic

I went to consultations at 9 places and narrowed it down to 2! 1. I liked that the consultation with the director and the consultant was detailed and kind. The director's explanation felt like listening to a seminar? I was recommended silicone for the nasal bridge + autologous costal cartilage for the nasal tip Surgery time: 2:30-3 hours, autologous costal cartilage chest scar: 2.5-3 cm Price: 4.7 million won Opened 1 year and a half ago / 16 years of experience? Since it hasn't been open long, there aren't many reviews, but all the reviews were good Some review photos I liked, and some I didn't There are more male reviews (I'm female) 2. The consultation with the director was fun He said my nose is so small that I shouldn't worry about anything else and should only worry about how to make it higher + he said he normally doesn't explain this much, but because my nose is so small, even after surgery, when others see it, it would just look like I naturally had a pretty nose~ Silicone for the nasal bridge + autologous costal cartilage for the nasal tip + ear cartilage for the nasal tip Surgery time: 2 hours, autologous costal cartilage chest scar: 2 cm Price: 5.5 million won (they said they'd discount 200,000 won if paid in full) Opened 5 years ago, 16 years of experience? They don't respond well after surgery Lots of reviews There are reviews like, 'A few months later, the nose became crooked, they don't respond well, the surgery went well but a large incision scar was left inside the nose, I'm in year 2 and the nose is lifted upward (but I don't want to blame the clinic?) The nasal tip came back down exactly like before, but they blamed the patient and changed their story (sent a threatening certified letter / an acquaintance also had the same nasal tip absorption)' ㄷㄷ But an acquaintance had surgery at #2 and it went well.. I like #2 better because I like the shape and the costal cartilage scar is smaller, but there are bad reviews, so I'm really torn;;; And #2 emphasized that using costal cartilage + ear cartilage for the nasal tip is better, saying they go out of their way to do it even though it's bothersome.. But I've also heard that ear cartilage detaches more easily than costal cartilage, so I'm curious about that too Which place would be better?